F*&! Joe Torre

Since Joe Torre breaks our hearts, this blog will break his balls. Every day of the season I will detail the errors, misjudgements, and omissions that make him the most overrated manger in the history of the game (even more than Tommy Lasorda!). But Joe Torre is not just one bum in hero's clothing (i.e. the pinstripes); he is the quintessential counterfeit of excellence, a figure who embodies the triumph of the ersatz that pervades every aspect of our culture. No organization in sport, nay in civilization generally, has manifested a committment to continuing greatness like the New York Yankees, a beacon to all, in every field of endeavor, that the best is always possible. How intolerable is it then that the Yankees should be managed by a mediocrity on stilts, a figure with a reputation for greatness without any of the attributes thereof. Beginning with Torre and ending with Torre, this blog will look to smash idols we create out of inadvertence, ignorance, and complacency.

Saturday, April 21, 2007

I DON'T BLAME TORRE FOR THIS COLLAPSE,

I blame him for the losses to follow. With an already stressed and overworked bullpen, torre removes Pettite in the 7th inning despite the fact that he had just struck out a batter. With a 6-2 lead, slow Joe simply has to rely on Pettite to get him 8 innings. If you lose by that strategy, so be it, but you now have rested a bullpen that badly needs it, and tomorrow is, as Scarlet O'Hara has it, another day. What Joe did was rely on the overworked by overworking them further, and now there's noone left to go to when Karstens and Wright need help. Andy Pettite was the only starter in this series with the experience to go deep in Fenway. If he fails to do so, well fair enough. But he was succeeding. Why in the world would you yank him? For Meyers? Bulletin to status quo: Meyers can't get anyone out when it counts, including Ortiz. For Vizcaino? No he just threw 30 pitches yesterday and got lit up. For Mo? Yes, but only to start an inning. I don't know if Boston would have gotten to Pettite, but there were no other reasonable options, and even if they did we'd be better off than we are now with the bullpen taxed to the breaking point. With respects to BGW, this is more of Torre's sentimental tomfoolery. He tries to assure his starter's won't lose well pitched games by pulling them at the first opportunity. The result is that they, and the team, win less of their well pitched games than they should.

This was on any account a crushing defeat, particularly since this was the one matchup in the Yankees' favor. Pettite is a better pitcher than Schilling and with the Yanks line-up, they need to win games like this. But any projection of Yankees' success over the long term of the season was predicated on Mo being Mo. Yes, he's had slow starts before. But I cannot remember him ever having an 8.5 ERA, nor blowing 2 leads of this magnitude in this fashion twice in a row. It is reasonable to wonder if we are witnessing the beginning of the end of an era of late-inning dominance, which would mean a continuation of the Yanks time in the wilderness of losing.

Before the series, I thought the Yanks would lose 2 games to 1 , and that would be fine given the state of their rotation and the imminent return of Wang. But when you lose a game like this to the bats of Crisp, Varitek and Cora, a sweep seems the only rational expectation. Weak starters and a depleted bullpen strengthen that expectation. And if that happens, the Yankees might well be playing for their season next week at the stadium. If they are 5 or more back at that point, the likelihood of their securing Clemens diminishes dramatically, and the likelihood of Boston signing him increases proportionately. I really don't see any way of conceiving what Joe Torre did to this team tonight as anything other than disaster. If the Yankee fans want a target for the venom they have in reserves owing to AROD's resurgence, Torr is their man. Let's see if we can drive him from the game.

3 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

I have no idea why Torre pulled Pettitte; but then I never understood why the Yankees didn't sign him after he went 3-1 with a 2.03 ERA in 5 postseason starts in 2003, so what do I know?

6:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Joe V -

Welcome back for another season
with a team that alternately lifts our spirits one day and stomps on them the next.

I was puzzled as well by Pettitte's departure, but I am more troubled by the failure of the bullpen. Putting aside that they won't be well-rested for the remainder of this series (not a small issue, granted), their inability to close out the game is disturbing. You are quite correct that the Yankees are in serious trouble if Rivera is losing his dominance.

Other small mistakes loom large in hindsight. Cano's failure to run hard out of the box on his drive off the Monster, allowing Manny to hold him to a single. Rookie mistake by a third-year player! A-Rod's throw to first in the pressure-packed 8th inning that pulled Mientkiewicz, cost an out and added a runner. I might be wrong about the strategy with this final point, but why was Mientkiewicz so far off the line that he got nowhere close to flagging down Crisp's two-hopper that became a bases-clearing triple? Crisp is left-handed, Mo throws cutters in to lefties, and pulling the ball seems to be the likely outcome. Smart baseball wins close games against good teams. Your referenced the '98 Yankees. I'll add that they played the defense and smart baseball that the 2007 version often lacks.

I am hoping that the team can stay close until the pitching gets healthy. This may be a rough weekend, but as the cliché goes, it's a long season - MUNSON

10:55 AM  
Blogger joe valente said...

Great point about Mientkiewicz. You always play the line in a situation like that. And given his bat, he needs to make every possible play to justify his position on the team. Even the defensive specialists on this team are nothing special.

And why pull Giambi for a pinchrunner. This is Fenway Park; the game is never over and no lead is safe. Boston found that out in game 4 of the massacre last year, The Yanks should have learned it form game four of the ACLS in 2004.

As for the bullpen's failure, I think it was Torre's. Why Vizcaino after his stint on Thursday? And why is Meyers still on this team. He stunk last year, he stinks now and he can't even get lefties out.

If you let Pettite finish the seventh (he had struck out the last batter he face), you have PRoctor for the eighth and its an entirely different affair--today we're talking about how the new-found depth in the bullpen saved their bacon. The fate of this bullpen is in Torre's hands, and of his myriad weaknesses as a manager, his inability to orchestrate his bullpen is the greatest.

12:10 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home